Okay guys, so this whole action figure hunt started because my nephew’s birthday is coming up, and he’s crazy about superheroes. I wanted to get him a decent one without wasting cash on junk or overpaying for something fancy he’d wreck in five minutes. Figured I might as well dive deep and compare the big brands properly.
Step 1: Listing the Big Players
First thing, I grabbed my laptop and just typed “best action figure brands” like anyone would. Scrolled through forums and toy review sites. Kept seeing these names pop up constantly:
-
For beginners/kids:
- Marvel Legends (around 20 bucks)
- McFarlane DC Multiverse (25-ish)
- Star Wars Black Series (usually 25-30)
-
For collectors/higher end:
- SHFiguarts (mostly 80+ but crazy detail)
- Mafex (even pricier, like 90-100+)
- NECA (weird because they do 30 dollar stuff AND 100+ movie figures)
Step 2: Store Hopping & Price Sticker Shock
Next morning, I hit actual stores. Target’s toy aisle had Marvel Legends and Black Series everywhere. Picked up a Spider-Man from each. Felt the plastic – Legends felt lighter, Black Series had nicer paint. Price tags: Legends 22.99, Black Series 27.99. Five bucks difference felt noticeable.
Then went to this collector’s shop downtown. Saw SHFiguarts Iron Man behind glass. Asked to hold it. Holy crap – die-cast parts, extra hands, faceplates. Smooth joints. Checked the tag: 89.99. Almost choked. Owner showed me Mafex Batman beside it – 104.99! Felt premium but man, that’s mortgage money for plastic.
Step 3: The Comparison Mess
Back home, I dumped screenshots of prices from Target, Walmart, Amazon, and eBay on my desktop. Big mistake. Marvel Legends prices bounced around like crazy – 19.99 on Amazon, 24.99 at Walmart for same figure. McFarlane’s stuff was oddly consistent except on eBay where scalpers wanted double.
Tried making a simple table:
-
Brands Avg Price Best For Plastic Feel
- Marvel Legends 20-25 Kids / casual fans Lightweight, okay joints
- SHFiguarts 80-100 Hardcore collectors Heavy, metal bits, butter joints
Gave up after six rows. Felt like homework. Noticed NECA haunted me – TMNT figures looked awesome at 35 bucks but their Alien line was 90. Why?!
Step 4: The “Aha” Realization
Sat staring at my nephew’s wishlist: basic Spider-Man. Realized dropping 100 bucks was stupid. Compared the 22.99 Marvel Legends Spidey to online pics of the 90-dollar imports. Yeah, imports look slicker, but a 7-year-old won’t care about ankle pivot joints. Felt dumb almost overspending.
For collectors though? Different story. If you display figures and pose them daily, those Mafex joints and paint apps justify the cost. But for play? Total waste.
Wrap-up
Ended up grabbing that Legends Spider-Man at Target. Nephew will probably lose the extra hands by Tuesday, but whatever. Learned something – brand tiers exist for reasons:
-
Cheap Stuff: Great for kids, decent quality for price.
Mid-range (NECA/McFarlane): Hits sweet spot between looks and price.
Import stuff: Bank-breaking beauties for display.
My advice? Set a budget FIRST. Almost tricked myself into buying art when I just needed a toy. Comparing without that? Endless rabbit hole. Also – check stores physically. Online prices lie.
